Now you can pay your insurance premium right here if your insurance carrier is listed below.

No need to keep track of phone numbers and addresses for each company that you use.  Just scroll down below to find your insurance company and click the appropriate button to make a payment or to get customer service for your insurance policy. 

Of course, if you have difficulty connecting or would like further help for any reason, our representatives here at the Schaefer Insurance Services agency are always glad to assist.  Just contact us to get help.

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP

To pay your Erie Insurance Group payment online follow this link:
https://www.erieinsurance.com/Applications/PolicyManagement/General/Billing/BillPay.aspx

or call 800-387-1492 to pay by telephone.

PROGRESSIVE INSURANCE COMPANY

Pay your Progressive Insurance Company premium online. 

or call 800-PROGRESSIVE

---

AGENCY INSURANCE COMPANY (AIC)

To pay your Agency Insurance Company (AIC) payment online follow this link:
https://www.myaicpolicy.com/Public/LoginPage.aspx

or call 800-492-5629 to pay by telephone. 

---

FOREMOST INSURANCE COMPANY

Visit their website and select Make a Payment (have your policy number handy).

AFLAC

To pay your AFLAC Insurance Company premium online follow this link:

https://my.aflac.com/login2/login.aspx

or call 800-99AFLAC

UTICA NATIONAL

To pay your Utica National Insurance Company premium follow this link:

https://secure.uticanational.com/CustomerCare/login.aspx

or call 800-866-1914

FIDELITY NATIONAL

To pay your Fidelity National Insurance Company premium follow this link:

http://pay.fidelityonline.com